Domestic violence: the order, the admission, and the denials

In October 2008 a domestic-violence master extended a protection order against him on a form finding that an act of domestic violence had occurred or that he represented a credible threat. At that hearing, the minutes record, he testified that the only time he laid hands on her was to stop her blocking him from leaving. The Supreme Court repeated that admission in a published 2013 opinion. In four filings between 2009 and 2014 he swore or wrote that he had never committed any act of domestic violence and that her application was a lie.

Illustration, not a photograph; no person is depicted. It stands for the document the record contains: the Extended Order for Protection Against Domestic Violence of October 10, 2008, No. FV08-03338, with its form finding "an act of domestic violence has occurred and/or you represent a credible threat." Nothing beyond what that order and the minutes say is shown or implied.

The two sides, quoted

form finding: "an act of domestic violence has occurred and/or you represent a credible threat"

Extended Order for Protection Against Domestic Violence, Second Judicial District Court, Family Division (domestic violence master), No. FV08-03338, October 10, 2008 (NSC No. 65289, Record on Appeal Vol. II, pp. 60-61)

he testified that "the only time he laid his hands on her was when he was trying to prevent her from blocking him from leaving."

Minutes of October 10, 2008 (filed as part of the other parent's Response to Petition, Part 2, NSC No. 59554, April 23, 2012, p. 2)

"he admitted that he had put his hands on her on one occasion."

Falconi v. Secretary of State, 129 Nev. Adv. Op. 28 (April 25, 2013), slip op. p. 3

"never once struck, assaulted, stalked, threatened to strike, assault, stalk, or harm"

His Petition for Judicial Review, No. CV09-03089, October 2009 (NSC No. 56169, Record on Appeal Vol. 2, p. 10)

"never committed any acts of domestic violence"

His Opening Brief in the same case, filed January 28, 2010 (id. at p. 67)

"never slapped, punched, or kicked her"

His Reply to [the other parent]'s Answer to Petition, NSC No. 59554, May 4, 2012, p. 3

her application was "complete with the lie that she was the victim of domestic violence."

His Proper Person Opening Brief, NSC No. 65289, 2014, p. 12
Context. The 2013 Supreme Court opinion made no finding that domestic violence occurred; the admission is its recital of his own testimony.

All contradictions